Hallock`s Cider Mill in Laurel

Loved the peach pie!

I used to go to Briermere Farms for my pies but recently discovered this small farm stand further down in Jamesport. In terms of flavor and crust, they top all the others I’ve tried in North Fork. Super fresh and it’s popular since they run out of most options by 5pm. The blueberry pie here is delicious. They are also known for their cheesecakes. Their key lime black bottom pie is fantastic as well, just tangy enough with the balance of dark chocolate and graham crust.I wouldn’t really bother with their crumb cakes, although the crumb topping itself looks great and the cake part is relatively moist, the part where they sit together can be a little dry and overall can be more flavorful. Do buy their pickled vegetables though, their carrots are crunchy and perfectly pickled with vinegar. A hearty portion too!

Clean great pies,jamed

Bad service

Fresh fruit and great pies. Not to mention ciders and juices that are great.

I found it overrated cookies were hard as a rock and expensive!!

Great Staff, really cute place and excellent pies, jams, preserves and drinks.

Great pies and very good cider

Crumb cake was delicious.

Fantastic place with incredible pecan pies and a large shop with all sorts of local homemade products. Of course the apple cider is amazing too.

You will not find better, fresher homemade pies on Long Island. Absolutely worth the trip and worth the money. Many different types of pie, but the classics are best in my opinion. Try the apple and the blueberry.

Great place to stop and visit and shop. A must stop.

Best pie on the planet. Did not try the cider. We bought key lime pie, brambleberry (something like that, which is a mix of blueberry and blackberry or something), and apple crumb. so so delicious. people were nice. easy to park. prices def reasonable.

The baked products are out of this world. There are farm fresh produce of great quality. Give yourself a treat and stop by 🦈

Great stuff delicious baked goods and Cider different flavors so good. I had the Cherry and regular!

Best pies on Long Island, and everything else is pretty good as well. Worth the drive and traffic.

Best pie we have ever tasted!!! Black cherry crumb Nirvana

I had multiple hairs in my pie. The service was horrible. The younger gentlemen was very rude to my parents. I believe his name is Hunter and he is part of the company. I will not be ordering anything else from this place again.

Great place for pies, cider, and jams. They’ve recently expanded the jams and jellies section - which makes it deliciously dangerous.

Very good variety of homemade items. Unfriendly and pricey Opinions Opinions

Great Italian Lemon Cheese cake. It is closed for the season until April.

People are unfriendly, and the prices are way to high. Why not just go to briermeire. Edit: The owner can''t say that everything they are doing is right, when they get the same complaint's

The best French dressing I've ever tasted in my life

Apple Cider Donuts are amazing!

Everyone who works there is quite pleasant... All produce and baked goods are super fresh.....

Amazing baked goods and you can't beat the fresh cider.

Nice place Friendly People and The Key Lime Pie is the Best !

Cute place. Overpriced like most places in the area. NOT A CIDER MILL just a shop. Disappointing and misleading to say it's a mill when it's not.

Great deserts

Delicious pies cakes ..visit at least twice a year ...reasonable prices for the quality of their goods...

Love this place quality merchandise, country store atmosphere

Nice people!!

This was a great place to go for pies, jams and cookies. The delicious smell of the baked pie as you enter the door.

Please dont buy the blueberry turnovers, they're mine

Always smells wonderful in there. Cookies, pies, and sauces are all delicious.

They have the freshest veggies and the worlds best pies! They are extremely friendly! The cider is always tasty and available in many different sizes. My family always makes a trip from West Islip to visit. We always come home with a car full of goodies. Fresh, tasty, and friendly is always a good combination. They have a large variety of jellies and fresh home made breads and pies. A visit is worth the trip!

Great Jams!

Best cider and soup!

What a wonderful place for sweets that taste like grandma made it. The apple pie is to die for! I won't go anywhere else for pies. The cookies are amazing too! They also have gluten free desserts which is nice. Their cider is amazing. Perfect!

Best place to shop mot pricey at all I love everything they stuff from soups to cookies.

Large assortment of jams, fresh pies, plants. prices good for what you get. Press better than briermers.

Great New England Clam Chowder

The peach cider was like finding an oasis in the desert after being stranded for days.

Quirky

Their blueberry pies are to die for. Apple donuts, blueberry turnovers, fresh mozzarella. Every time we drive up to the island, we have to stop here!!!

Best cider around, stop here often and it's a 60+ mile drive. Their baked goods are really top shelf,pies are awesome and customer service is great.

The apple cider is fabulous

Best cheesecake you'll ever find

No photo will capture the fantastic, mouthwatering aromas emanating from inside; you have to come here to appreciate it and, trust me, you won't regret it. Also, you won't be able to leave empty-handed, the pies and other baked goods are impossible to resist.

Terrific...clean tasting crispness never had before in their grape juice! Fattest and tastiest zvoideles (?) Ever!Vanilla peaches to die for!Produce, pies all pure country fresh, not to mention the chowders!